Sunday, 16 February 2014

भगोड़ा


When Aam Adami Party (AAP) was formed and decided to contest the election, many people ridiculed them and predicted that they won’t make any impact on Indian politics. This was because many believe that the social movements can’t be successful as a political party. They are integral and important part of democracy but have to remain apolitical and act as a pressure group on the ruling class from outside. We have seen a rise and a fall of Sharad Joshi. But AAP proved differently and exception to this belief.

When they demonstrated fantastic performance in Delhi Assembly Election in Dec-13, all the conventional wisdom of Indian politics collapsed. Many rightly said that if Delhiites would have slightest idea that AAP can reach near to half way mark, they would have given them decisive majority. All main stream political parties have forgotten the basic principles of contesting election such as person to person contact, informal meeting with the voters and society during the campaign. They are now more focused on money powered, big rallies, personalities, celebrities, television debates and very artificial sounding campaign.

In contrast, AAP focused on building network at ground level, empowering common man, self-motivated activism, constructive usage of social media, funding election through micro finance from voters and transparency in the entire approach. Selecting new faces brought the freshness and energy into their campaign. Their idea of separate manifesto for each constituency was so innovative that other parties have to follow the suit. The most importantly, after so many years of democracy, a common man believed that the election can be fought without money power, connect with elites, a dynast and charismatic oratory skills. Their spectacular performance in Delhi election had profound impact across the country. After so many years, a common man felt that established can be defeated and they can be a part of government! AAP gave hope to the nation that politics can be clean and forced mainstream political parties to introspect.

All initial euphoria started converting into disarray in few days. AAP could not understand the difference between an activist and a ruler. Delhiites happily accepted that they had taken support from Congress for forming a government. Now it was a time to demonstrate to the nation that common man can run the government. However, they did very little to build upon their distinctive feature and prepare a ground work on fulfilling their manifesto. The unexpected windfall of success went into the heads of Arvind Kejriwal and his team and started dreaming at national level. Their confrontational, publicity seeking, heroism, populistic, threatening, anarchist and chaotic way of governance is highly deplorable. Their approach of demonizing politicians, bureaucrats, government servants, industrialists is highly reprehensible. They are misleading the nation. They knew that they can’t introduce Jan Lokpal bill when parliament has already passed Lokpal bill. The state responsibility is to accept it in the state. The state has complete liberty of changing/modifying it. However, AAP was not interested in the constitutional way. The very reason of resignation of government is unconvincing when none asked for their resignation, Congress did not withdraw their support and none sought for no-confidence motion. They approached voters whether to accept Congress’s unconditional support or not but conveniently forgotten them while resigning. They had moral ground for resigning as they had already lost the majority on the floor. But they conveniently ignored it and continued.

Nobody joins politics to sit in the opposition perpetually or help defeating others or get defeated, but to govern as per their principles, ambition and promises within the constitutional framework. Running government is all about patience, courage, belief, firmness, digesting criticism, dialogue, consultation, confrontation, cooperation and occasional receding. But AAP chose to run away from the responsibilities.
The experiment of AAP is disastrously failed. AAP may take very high moral ground. But they helped Congress, to whom they have been criticizing for corruption, to grab the government with the least number of MLA’s. Now Congress government in the center rules Delhi under Presidential Rule! I wonder what they have achieved by resigning. They have committed a big crime by pushing Delhiites into one more election. Voters of India are very wise. They will give you ONLY one chance and AAP has missed it!

Wednesday, 12 February 2014

Privacy is My Right!


One experiences all sort of emotions while driving on our roads. The most prominent one is rage on the fellow citizen who has given damn to your safety or rights while on the road. Many a times, we feel that let me chase him out and give him back! One may also fantasize of veiled attack on him. Here is the way!

Today Big Data, Social media, mobile and internet have certainly given such possibilities. Few days back, Maharashtra RTO has given a number (09212357123). If you send an SMS VAHAH and vehicle number, a return SMS will provide the owner’s name. (It is still working but personal information is not sent now). Once the name is available, it is very easy to get his photo, telephone number and other details on social media websites such as Linkedin, Facebook, Google+ etc. Today image search (http://images.google.com/ ) is also possible. Such search engine can give photos of entire family and friend’s network of that person.

Today so much of information is available online than never before. One can get private information of a person based on his public information. Getting someone’s PAN number is very easy. Banks, utility suppliers and even NSDL systems are very prone for hacking. Even hacking is not needed. Small bribe can get you anyone’s PAN number. Once it is available, access to all his financial information is possible. Income Tax department’s website Traces (tdscpc.gov.in) has all the information about bank accounts, FD, shares and mutual funds. There is one organization called CIBIL. Its major stakeholder is TransUnion (of USA). The overseas companies hold 43% stake in this company and remaining stake is held by various Indian Banks. The all member financial companies provide financial information of an individual to this company. CIBIL has consolidated information of credit card transactions, any types of loan and properties bought on loan. Do you still think that your financial information is secret?

We see proliferation of Android phones and usage of gmail, Facebook, whatsApp on it. Go to Settings and click on apps. It gives a list of all the apps installed on the phone. Click on whatsApp, you will be astonished to see that it practically collects everything like geo location, contacts, groups, calling details, SMS and can directly modify/change/delete settings. The same is for other apps as well. Complete control on your phone!

Remember Govt. instructing Blackberry to provide unencrypted data or stop the services in India? Blackberry had to oblige unwillingly. Govt. collects data from internet traffic. We have already provided our biometric information through Aadhar Card. It is very easy to develop a system which will provide consolidated view of NSDL, Traces, CIBIL and Adhaar. The day is not far away that each citizen would be mapped! It is essentially good and useful but your personal information can be sensitive information too!
Just hold your breath! Do you think ONLY Govt. of India collects this information? Big Brother USA is also collecting it across the globe under the pretext of anti-terrorism operations. US’s National Security Agency (NSA) has built a huge data center in Utah which collects data from global internet traffic. They forced Microsoft, Google, Yahoo, Skype, YouTube, whatsApp etc. to open their systems for collecting data. Now just imagine how much personal information you provide to these websites! By now Big Brother knows everything about you! This is not just enough. NSA used Microsoft’s Windows update to spread Flame Malware to target few countries in past. One can argue that there is nothing for me to hide. But we must understand our privacy is a basic building block of our freedom and democracy is built upon freedom!

Friday, 24 January 2014

Fear!


Other day, I was listening to a poem by Kavi Grace “भय इथले संपत नाही’ composed by Hridaynath Mangeshkar and sung by Lata Didi on Vividh Bharati. I wondered; can human race get rid of fear? Then I realized that it has been used for commercial benefit since ages and it is the core principle of many businesses.

Religion is the first and foremost entity who has been exploiting it since centuries. Believe me no religion is exception to it. Let’s talk about my religion. Almost all the pooja’s are example of it. Most of them have very noble purpose. But we have already forgotten the basic principles behind it and we do it out of fear. The same is being exploited by our priest. Most of us perform Satyanarayan Pooja. Listen to those 5 Adhyay priest narrates during the pooja. All of them say that if you do not perform the pooja as promised, it will bring bad luck to you. Many of us just do it not to break the tradition or out of fear.  

The next such community is Astrologers! The irony is that people have even developed the software for so-called science. In fact, many will try to convince you that how it is scientific and based on statistics but lack single evidence! Once I heard an interview of Sharad Upadhye a famous astrologer. She was asking many questions on gems and precious stones to him. He was explaining the benefits of them. At the end she asked him a question after looking at many rings in his hand. What are those precious stones? He laughed and said that all of them are dummy stones! Communities who have never seen or prepared their horoscope have started making it in recent days. Usage of horoscope for fixing marriages has increased to disgusting level and all out of fear! Vastu Shastra, Feng Shui and what not! Today no builder even dare to build south facing flat! Ironically, richest, and famous shops on Laxmi road in Pune are South facing!

Fear sells and can get you good money is a new realization to the profession who is not supposed to exploit it. It is the medical profession! Bird Flu is a classic example of it. In fact, there were very few human deaths due to bird flu. But fear of bird flu was sold across the globe and one pharma company made fortune in it. The same thing was repeated during swine flu. All of us have experienced deserted streets during its outbreak in 2009.  Do you know that there are no convincing test results that show Tamiflu cures Swine flu? Many NGO’s have demanded complete test results of Tamiflu. But Roche (only one manufacture in the world) had never provided any comprehensive test results on its capability of curing swine flu or controlling its epidemic.  Roche made billions of dollars in selling this medicine throughout the globe!

Last but not least, the political parties use the same model for garnering the votes. No political party is exception to it! Christianity is in danger was sold by George Bush in 2005. The entire international politics is played on the tenets of fear whether it is Iran or Iraq or any other so called rogue nations.
We are taught to live in fear! In fact, we have institutionalized fear! Insurance companies are the great example of it. Fear of not getting good school, fear of not getting good marks and good college, fear of not getting good job, fear of losing the job and finally fear of death! You would agree that all of these fears have already transformed into business for someone else. I wonder when we will learn to live with courage, as rationalist and with happiness! But where is the school for them!

Wednesday, 8 January 2014

Janata Morcha to AAP


1974 to 1975 has been very eventful days in post-independence history of India. The student of Gujarat started protest against price rise. This demonstration transformed into state wide demonstration under the banner of Nav Nirman Andolan in 1974. Mr. Morarji Desai of Congress (O) rode the popular wave and became the leader of the agitation. The agitation forced Chief Minister Chimanbhai Patel of Congress (R) to resign in Feb-1974. Mrs. Indira Gandhi imposed Presidential Rule in the state. But State Assembly had to be dissolved amid tremendous pressure from this movement. The State Assembly elections were held in 1975 and Janata Morcha won the Assembly Election on 12-June-1975.

At the same time in 1974, the student of Bihar started their protest against misrule, corruption, rise in inflation, unemployment in Congress (R) government. This state-wide Bihar Movement was supported by all student organizations except organization belonged to Congress. Jayaprakash Narayan (JP) provided leadership to this movement and gave a call for “Total Revolution”. Unlike in Gujarat, Mrs. Gandhi did not dismiss the Chief Minister and curbed the agitation forcefully.

The famous Railways strike was led by George Fernandes in Feb-1974. All Railway unions came together under his leadership. The entire nation was brought to complete halt. Their demands were better wages and better working condition. The strike was not really successful. Government ensured divisions in the protesters and George Fernandes finally called it off after 19 days of strike.

You can imagine, Mrs. Gandhi was facing tremendous civic disobedience in many parts of the country. The last nail on coffin was a judgment of Allahabad High Court on 12-June-1975. Raj Narain who was defeated by Mrs. Gandhi in 1971 election filed a case against her for misusing government machinery for election purpose. Incidentally, Mr. Shanti Bhushan (Father of Prashant Bhushan of Aam Adami Party) fought for Raj Narain. The court found her guilty, cancelled her election and banned her from contesting election for 6 years. She approached Supreme Court and Court upheld High Court judgment on 24-Jun-1975.

On the next day (25-June-1975) JP held a massive rally in New Delhi. He demanded her resignation and declared non-cooperation movement similar to what Mahatma Gandhi called during Independence struggle. In the midnight, she declared the state of Emergency and democracy was brought to complete halt. She immediately dismissed Government of Gujarat and Tamil Nadu and imposed President’s rule there.    

Although, Janata Morcha was formed in 1974, its real fight against Congress and Mrs. Gandhi started after declaration of Emergency. Janata Morcha consists of all Socialist Parties, Congress (O) and Jan Sangh. It gave new political platform to aam adami. It also gave lot of new leaders to the country. 1) Lalu Prasad Yadav: A lawyer and Masters in Political Science. He was student leader in Patna University. He played pivotal role in Bihar Movement in 1974 and later in JP movement. 2) Mulayam Singh Yadav: Master in Political Science. Strong follower of Ram Manohar Lohia and Charan Singh became part of JP movement. 3) George Fernandes: Born in middle class family in Mangalore, famous Union Leader from Mumbai. 4) Sharad Yadav: Gold medalist in Electrical Engineering from Jabalpur Engineering College and became a part of JP movement. 5) Nitish Kumar: Civil Engineer from NIT Patna and participated in JP’s movement in 1974.  6) Dr. Subramaniam Swamy: Doctorate from Harvard University. Mrs. Gandhi expelled him from IIT. He joined JP movement during Emergency.

There were host of other leaders such as Morarji Desai, Chandrashekhar, Ramkrishna Hegde, Devi Lal, Sikander Bakt, Deve Gowda of Congress (O) who joined JP movement and became the part of Janata Party. There were few ex-congressman such as Biju Patnaik, Charan Singh etc. became the part of Janata Morcha and finally part of Janata Party. Jan Sangh leaders like Atal Bihari Vajpayee, L. K. Advani, Vijayaraje Scindia also became part of Janata Morcha during emergency and then became part of Janata Party.

Janata Party’s landslide victory in general election in 1977 is a golden page in history of civic movement in India. It not only brought the first non-congress government but also changed the political fabric of India. Janata Party’s diverse folks could not keep them together after a huge success. A common goal (of defeating Mrs. Gandhi) could not keep them united. Their government fell down in 2.5 years due to internal differences. They forgot JP’s call of “Total Revolution” and many felt that it was impractical! As Janata Party could not live up to the trust shown by citizen of this country, they forgot atrocities and autocracy of Mrs. Gandhi during Emergency and elected her Prime Minister of India in 1980 once again. Socialist Party and thought started disintegrating since then and now it is confined to few states. It is completely wiped out from state like Maharashtra, Gujarat, Rajasthan, MP, etc.

They say history repeats! Here we come in 2009-10. CAG reported large scale irregularities in allocation of 2G spectrum. Initially, people like Kapil Sibbal said that there was no loss to exchequer. But we saw imprisonment of A. Raja. In 2012, CAG once again reported large scale irregularities in allocation of Coal deposits. Prime Minister was coal minister during this period. There is still no conviction in this case. These two scams along with inaccessible and very weak PM, dual power center at center tarnished the image of Congress government. On other side, corruption charges against B. S. Yeddyurappa, CM of Karnataka, forced him to resign in 2011. Corruption cases against Madhu Koda, Lalu Prasad Yadav, disproportionate asset case against Mulayam Singh Yadav, corruption in Common Wealth Games etc. created an impression within the country that all the political parties are corrupt especially two major parties i.e. INC and BJP.

In April 2011, Anna Hazare started his fast for Jan lokpal bill. Many compared his agitation with JP’s one. He ended his fast after 98 hrs. after government agreed to set up a Joint Drafting Committee. Anna gave a deadline to the government of 15-Aug-11 to pass the bill. The committee failed to agree on the terms of the bill and government filed their own version of bill in Aug 2011. Anna and his team felt that the government version of Lokpal bill is very weak and will be ineffective in curbing corruption. They asked for permission for fast and agitation against bill in Aug-2011. It was given with lot of conditions. On 16-Aug, Anna was taken into preventive custody but he instructed his followers to continue with the protest. His arrest resulted into huge outcry across the country and government released him on the same evening. He refused to come out of jail and started his indefinite fast from jail. Thank God they did not repeat the mistake of Mrs. Gandhi! Finally government agreed to his demands and allowed him to start his agitation from Ramlila Ground. This agitation continued for 12 days. The impromptu demonstration were held across the country and citizen showed solidarity with Anna’s movement. This agitation brought completely new faces in front us. 1) Arvind Kejriwal: IITian, ex-IRS officer, RTI activist, Magsaysay award winner. 2) Manish Sisodia: Journalist and social worker worked with Arvind Kejriwal since beginning. 3) Prashant Bhushan: IIT drop out, Lawyer and RTI activist. Specialist in PIL. 4) Kumar Vishwas: Professor of Hindi and appeared first time in Anna movement 5) Yogendra Yadav: Social Scientist and Sr. fellow at CSDS. He was advisor to Rahul Gandhi. Became part of Anna movement in 2011.

Arvind Kejriwal felt that political party is needed for fight against corruption. Anna wanted to keep it non-political movement. After the difference with Anna, he formed Aam Adami Party (AAP) in Nov-2012. The main agenda of the party is to fight against corruption and fight against main parties i.e. INC and BJP.

After winning second largest seats in New Delhi Assembly election, there are new hopes from AAP. The country is witnessing new enthusiasm as famous personalities like Bala of Infosys, Meera Sanyal, CEO of RBS India, and Capt. Gopinath of Deccan Airways have joined AAP. As said earlier, there is large section of society who is fade up of corruption of INC and weak government at the center. But they do not want to align with BJP either. Although, there are many so called socialist parties in India, but they became personal properties of some families with less or no principles of socialism being practiced. Socialist people in states like Maharashtra, MP, Gujarat do not have any political space in their respective states. In short, it created big vacuum in politics and Kejriwal encashed this opportunity. AAP has given new hopes to these scattered socialists across India. This is definitely sizeable votes to win 25-50 seats in next General Election. They will mostly impact INC but they would be big spoilers for most of the established parties as well. Even if they win 25 seats in next general election, they can dislodge NAMO’s dream of becoming Prime Minister. As per my earlier calculation, AAP can change the equation as follows,

Parties
Before AAP
After AAP
UPA
125
110
NDA
250
245
Third Front
168
163
AAP
25
Total
543
543


  

The parties like TMC, YSR Congress, who would not align with INC, would immediately align with AAP. As said earlier, most of AAP supporters are either socialist or communist. The simple calculation (25 + 150 of third front) and with external support of congress, AAP can form the government in next general election. If that happens, it would be very fragile government as country experienced during the days of Deve Gowda, Chandrashekhar or I. K. Gujral and push the country back by another 10 years.

There is large similarity between Janata Party and AAP. People took the advantage of popularity of JP in Janata Morcha and similarly, Kejriwal and team took advantage of Anna’s popularity. Janata party fought against Mrs. Indira Gandhi and AAP is fighting against Congress and BJP. Janata party initially declared many popularistic policies such as lowering sugar prices, banning liquor etc. AAP is also doing the same. Janata Party declared that they would file cases against Mrs. Gandhi, Sanjay Gandhi and other corrupt congress leaders. But not a single case saw a day of light. Mr. Kejriwal is also saying the same. The difference in Janata Party and AAP is that AAP has not allowed any political party to merge with them. Another difference is that Janata Party never dislodged JP and JP never left Janata party in his life. However, Kejriwal and company have already dislodged Anna and Anna has already disowned AAP.  AAP has to prove the mettle by delivering in New Delhi as per their manifesto. They need to serve the country for some time and get the experience of running government. We already have one experience of giving central government to newly formed party. We can’t afford it once again. Now we have to decide whether we want strong government or weak government and vote accordingly!

Saturday, 4 January 2014

At Riyadh Airport


Few days back, I was waiting for my turn in check-in line of Jet Airways at Riyadh Airport. Incidentally, Pakistan International Airline’s (PIA) counter was at the left hand side and British Airways’s counter was at the right hand side of me. Timings of Peshawar, Mumbai, and London flights were at similar time and hence check-in of all these three flights was going on simultaneously. As usual Jet Airway had some technical problems in check-in and I was standing at the same location for almost 1 hrs. What do you do for one hour standing in line? Observe the crowd!!

PIA’s check-in lines were moving very fast.  All the passengers were in typical Pathani white attire. Majority of them were over 6 FT tall and very good build. Everyone had typical Pathani beard. People in my line were looking like they were facing acute malnutrition. There was not a single woman in the entire crowd! Everyone was carrying lot of luggage, no suitcase, luggage were tied with nylon rope.  Almost everyone was carrying 20 L water bottle wrapped in plastic bag. I was surprised to see that. Come on all these guys are going out of desert and not going to desert!! I was very curious about those water bottles and started observing keenly. Then, I observed that “Zam-Zam” was written on it. There was a picture of Mecca mosque on some of the bottles. I thought there must some connection between Mecca and these water bottles. Subsequently, I confirmed from Wikipedia that the water from holy mosque is called Zam-Zam and has very interesting story about it in full of desert!! I felt very embarrassed about myself and felt that how little I know about other religion.

Incidentally, cabby who dropped me at the airport was also a Pathan and was from nearby Peshawar. I tried communicating with him while coming to the airport. He was very simple, innocent, humble and under educated person (Nowadays, I am afraid of calling someone illiterate as day by day I am realizing that education and literacy do not have any relationship). There was no trace of traditional hatred of India and Pakistan. After some conversation, I asked him in which language you are talking to me? He immediately replied me “in Urdu”. Then I asked him, what do think, in which language I am talking to you? He was little confused with my question and didn’t answer. I told him “in Hindi”.  Then, I asked him do you see any difference in these two languages?  He said that they watch so many Hindi movies so they understand all the Hindi words. Then I asked him “What is your mother tongue?” He replied, “Pashtun”. He added, he speaks in Pashtun with family members and in Peshawar and can speak in Urdu as it is their National Language. Then I asked him which part of Pakistan speak Urdu as their mother tongue. He was completely surprised with my question and started murmuring Sindh speak Sindhi, Punjab speak Punjabi, their region speaks Pashtun. As an innocent person, he started wondering why is Urdu their National Language? Then I asked him one more question. Do you know where did Urdu born as a language? He was completely speechless. I thought let me not answer him these questions and got down from taxi as we were already at the airport.
My conversion with cabby few minutes back and looking at those 500 odd Pathans , 2000 years of history of Indian subcontinent ran through my mind in a flash. I remembered Taxshila University, I remembered Chanakya and  Chandragupt Maurya, I remembered defeat of Alexander, I remembered republic of Malav and Shudrak, I remembered Vir Savarkar’s book named “6 Golden Pages of Indian History”. I remembered Savarkar’s theory of “Sadgun Vikruti” (virtuous perversity), remembered the perversities like Sindhu Bandi (Social prohibition if someone crosses Sindhu River), Shuddhi Bandi (Social prohibition to return to Hinduism, if someone converts to any other religion). If these perversities would have not been prevalent in Hinduism, today all those Pathans would have been called White Hindus under Hindu Kush Mountain. Then, I remembered one more theory of Savarkar; religious conversion leads to partition of nation. If our ancestors would have been wise enough and not allowed religious conversion or taken efforts to bring back our brothers to Hinduism, today we would have seen Undivided Bharat! Just imagine if these Pathans were to be part of Indian Military; who could defeat this country in the world!! Just imagine if they were to be part of our Cricket or Football Team; where would have been our nation in the sports today!! But then I suddenly came back to present and felt very embarrassed because it is easy to blame our ancestors but what are we doing today!!!!

Vidarbha State:


Recent declaration of separate Telangana state has resulted into new spate of demand for independent state. It has given new hopes to many people who are aspiring for separate state for them. There are lot of discussions on these demands in the print, electronic and social media. Everyone will have his/her own opinion on it. Similarly, I do have my own opinion on it. Everyone has freedom to accept or reject it. But I would like to exercise my freedom of expression here.

Many people like me would like to see Vidarbha as a separate state. There are certain arguments in its favor and against it. I would like to ponder over some of them and share my point of view. Let’s take some of the factors which are argued against the formation of separate Vidarbha.

1.       Vidarbha can’t survive on its own: Many people argue that independent Vidarbha will not be able to generate sufficient revenue which will be enough for running its own affairs. They argue she is currently getting funds which are actually generated in cities like Mumbai, Pune etc. Please see the following points and then see merits in these arguments,

a.       There are so many perennial rivers like Wainganaga, Wardha, Vena etc. run through many districts of Vidarbha. Their basins have created very fertile land in the region. In short, it has good amount of water and fertile land.

b.      Vidarbha produces variety of crops. The region produces rice, wheat, jawar, pulses, soybean and cash crops like cotton and oranges. In short, it is self-sufficient in food grains.

c.       Vidarbha is completely self-sufficient in electric power.

d.      Vidarbha is rich in ore deposits. She has big reserves of Coal, Manganese, Calcium, Mica etc. Rest of Maharashtra lacks it.

e.      All major cities and district headquarters are connected with rail network. Large railway junctions are there in Nagpur, Wardha and Ballarpur. In short, good infrastructure for transportation.

f.        Nagpur is located in the center of the region and has operational airport. It has good connectivity with all the major cities in India.

g.       Educational institutes like VRCE, GMC and LIT have earned their name in the world. In short, good infrastructure for higher education.

h.      Vidarbha has 50% of total forest in Maharashtra. There are many reserve forests. The forest produce such as Tendu leaves, Moha flowers, bamboo, teak wood, Sandal wood and other precious forest produce can help the economy. In addition to that, there are lot of historical places. In short, Vidarbha can become a very good destination for tourism.  

2.       Vidarbha does not have good leadership: This statement is similar to what Winston Churchill had said once. He was democratically elected Prime Minister of UK and was absolutely not in favor of granting independence to India. He said that Indian Politicians are not ready / mature enough to run the country! Leadership will evolve, if opportunity is given.  India has progressed against Churchill’s will. Vidarbha will progress against the will of opposing people.

3.       Agitation is not as effective as Telangana: What do you expect? Demands would be fulfilled only when some people are killed in the agitation or public life is disrupted after huge demonstrations. Demand should be agreed / fulfilled in peaceful and democratic manner.

4.       Vidarbha does not have sea boundary: So what!! Even New Delhi does not have sea port. There are so many states which are prosperous and progressing without any sea port.

Then I wonder what would be the reasons for opposing the demand for separate Vidarbha. I see the following factors which are responsible for it.

1.       Vidarbha provides most of the power required for Maharashtra. Rural area in Vidarbha has to face long load shading so that cities in Western Maharashtra can get 24 X 7 electricity.

2.       It is easier to grab agricultural land in Vidarbha under the pretext of irrigation projects and divert the water outside of Vidarbha. Current ruling elite can’t dare to do it in western Maharashtra.

3.       Vidarbha has 50% of the total forest in Maharashtra. The Forest Minister is from Sangali District where there is negligible forest. But 100% funds can be diverted to rest of the Maharashtra.

4.       Central government’s funds, which are meant for Vidarbha, can be diverted to other part of Maharashtra. We have seen this happening when PM visited suicide affected region and declared the separate funds for Vidarbha. The Govt. of Maharashtra diverted it to the rest of Maharashtra.

In short, leaders of western Maharashtra can achieve the progress of their region at the cost of Vidarbha!

Once it was very prosperous region. We hear the stories of its prosperity from our older generation. Then what happened now? There is large scale migration of educated youth, Agricultural produce has come down, government does not give good rates to cotton, rice, there are less employment opportunities, so many projects are declared but they are not completed yet. We need to think over it! The power sharing in Maharashtra is completely skewed. There are 4 ministers from Sangali district alone. But there are many districts in Vidarbha who do not any representation in the ministry.

 What are the advantages, if a separate Vidarbha state is formed?

1.       Today, the entire Maharashtra’s politics is controlled by Maratha community. Maharashtra cannot get any non-Maratha Chief Minister. There is no dominating community in Vidarbha. Therefore, there is equal opportunity for everyone. The leader will be selected based on his/her merit and contribution.

2.       Nagpur has complete infrastructure required for Capital (as it was earlier capital of C P & Berar). It is headquarter of many public sector companies, railway divisions and research institutes. Reserve Bank is also there.

3.       Nagpur is in the middle of the Vidarbha. People will not have to travel long distance to reach to state capital. 

4.       All the development funds would be available at her disposal. The corruption cannot be eradicated. But the current practice of state government of diverting entire funds elsewhere will stop and Vidarbha can progress faster than now.

5.       Today, there are very few industries in Nagpur. But the rest of the Vidarbha has negligible industry. There would be renewed focus on industrial growth and cities like Amaravati, Akola and Chandrapur can become new industrial hub and can generate more employment opportunities.

6.       The new state will be with surplus energy. There is sufficient water. It would be very easy to attract industries in the region.

7.       New state can promote new set of industries based on agricultural and forest produce.

8.       Today youth (especially engineers) of Vidarbha have to search for a job in Pune, Mumbai, Hyderabad, Bangalore etc. This migration cannot be stopped overnight. But separate state will create such opportunities which will help to stop/reduce such migration in next 10-15 years.
In short, the independent Vidarbha would be viable, self-reliant, prosperous, progressive state. It will certainly demonstrate the leadership and can be a good example of creating smaller states for good governance. Therefore, I strongly support for separate Vidarbha! Do You?

15-Aug-2013


On the occasion of Independence Day, I got up early in the morning and got ready as we wanted to attend Independence Day celebration at our son’s school. As I got into car and put on my favorite FM radio channel Vividh Bharati, our honorable Prime Minister’s speech from Red Fort started. I listened to initial few sentences and I was completely disappointed with his speech. I immediately said to my wife, “Is this an election speech? And PM is addressing to Congress rally?” There were so many of his statements which I could not digest or agree. Therefore, I downloaded complete text of his speech from internet and read it. To my surprise, my initial impression was vindicated. See some of his statements and make your own opinion.

1.       In the last 9 years, support prices for various crops have been enhanced as never before.

2.       The average annual rate of agricultural growth in the 11th Plan was 3.6, which is more than both the 9th and 10th Plan levels.

3.       In the period 2004 to 2011, rural per-capita consumption has increased four times faster than earlier.

4.       Whatever definition we may adopt, it cannot be denied that the pace of reduction in poverty has increased after 2004.

5.       Almost all our children are today being imparted education in Primary schools.

6.       We have implemented the Health Mission in urban areas also. This will result in both expansion and improvement of health services in such areas.

7.       For ensuring better safety and security for women, we have strengthened the law dealing with offences against women.

8.       There has been good progress in the last 9 years in the infrastructure sector. About 2 lakh km of new roads have been constructed for connecting villages under the Pradhan Mantri Gramin Sadak Yojana. More than 37,000 km of new Highways have been built, facilitating travel and trade.

9.       More than 40 airports have been built or upgraded.

10.   In 2004, only 7 percent of the people had telephone connections. Today, 73 percent enjoy this facility. In rural areas, this figure has gone up from 2 to 40.

11.   There has been a record addition to our capacity for electricity generation.

12.   There has been a reduction in terrorist and Naxal violence.

He refuted his own claim in point #11 and further said “Inadequate supply of coal had become a major problem affecting our efforts for increasing electricity generation.” I felt he was telling blatant lie to entire nation standing under Tricolor! 

He mentioned “In the last 9 years” seven times in the speech and said “after 2004” four times. I thought he forgot that he is first Prime Minister of India and then UPA or Congress’s.

Now see his statement. “However, it is not only our country that is facing economic difficulties. The last year has been difficult for the world economy as a whole. Major European nations are experiencing a slowdown these days. All over the world, there has been a slump in export markets. All developing countries have slowed down.” This statement is completing misleading the nation. Although, many countries are facing economic problems, but they are not facing inflation to the extent we are facing today.  No European countries’ or Japan’s currency are devaluating as our Indian Rupee is. The economic PM conveniently avoided these issues.

Instead of mentioning only Congress Prime Minister in his speech, it would have been better, if he would have attracted people attention towards the real problems our nation is facing today and shared his vision to handle them.  He should have addressed the issue of inflation, Rupee’s free fall, rampant corruption at all level of government, issue of rising crime against women, concerns toward security of our borders, his stand on demands of separate statehood etc. There are so many important bills pending in Parliament such as Police reform bill, Citizen’s right, rights of physically challenged people to name the few. He should have given definite schedule for passing Lokpal Bill, Women reservation bill.

This is not the first time he lied to the nation, he did the same thing when 2G scam, Coal scam broke and passed the buck to his ministers.

Just one day before, one submarine exploded and destroyed in dockyard in Mumbai. Is this the first accident in arm forces? Country has stopped counting accidents of MIG fighter planes now. Our brave soldiers are dying because of shear negligence, human error and poor quality of equipment. This is really worrisome. This brings serious doubt about our preparedness for our defense!

Where have we reached after 66 years of Independence?

Our borders are not secured today. One side China is entering in our territory on every day. Pakistan is attaching our post almost every day. Border fencing is almost broken at Bangladesh border resulting into uncontrolled infiltration. Our relations with Nepal and Sri Lanka is all time low!

Parliament Affair Minister stalls the proceeding of Parliament when question is asked about their leader’s son-in-law. The opposition party does not allow Parliament to function on small-small issues. Sometimes one gets the feeling that Parliament disruption is orchestrated in consultation with each other. Both Loksabha Speaker and Deputy Chairman of Rajyasabha seem to be helpless and very weak to control their houses. The main two political parties fight in Parliament and in TV studio.

The country has a PM from Rajyasabha as he may not get elected in Loksabha. He has to get elected from safe place in Assam away from his home where he never gives his vote in any election. His attendance is Parliament is abysmally low. He does not give any statement on major issues of the nation, avoids interaction with the citizen. He is highly educated but does not stop flattery of one family!

It was very sad to see people in Vidarbha, Bengal, and Assam on the street on Independence Day and demanding for separate state rather than celebrating Independence Day. It shows that the people’s aspirations are not met.
In midst of lot of pessimism and negativity, there is still a hope of emerging India as strong democratic nation. Although late, but the history which happened in mid-July, appeared on mainstream media few days back. The tribal girls of Hutup village in Jharkhand won the Bronze medal U-14 Gasteiz Cup in Spain. We complain about lack of support for sport in this country, but they fought against all odds and travelled across 7 seas and made their homeland proud. Their commitment, dedication, hard work, team work, fighting spirit and desire to dream is very inspiring story for all of us. This gives the hope that Young India will fight back against all odds and bring the nation where she deserves!